Fishing Bags: Rucksack, Carryall or Rod Bag?

Most anglers start with one bag and end up with four. That is not greed — it is because a two-hour margin session and a 48-hour overnight need different things, and no single bag does both well.
This guide explains the main types, what each is genuinely good at, the specifications worth paying for, and a packing baseline you can adapt. The goal is not the biggest bag; it is carrying exactly what you use and nothing you do not.
In this guide
The four bag types
| Type | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Rucksack | Carries weight comfortably over distance; keeps hands free | Slower access; everything comes out to reach the bottom |
| Carryall / holdall | Wide opening, easy access, sits flat on the bank | Uncomfortable to carry far; one shoulder |
| Rod bag / holdall | Protects made-up rods and reels | Not a general bag; adds length to your load |
| Cool / bait bag | Keeps bait and food at temperature; separate from tackle | Single purpose; extra item to carry |
The realistic two-bag setup is a rucksack for tackle and a rod holdall for rods. If you fish from a barrow or a short walk from the car, a carryall replaces the rucksack and is faster to work from. Bait goes in its own bag either way — you do not want a leaking bait bag inside your tackle.
Capacity: short, day and overnight
- Short session (2–4 hours): 20–30 litres. One rig wallet, a small tackle box, bait, scales, forceps, a landing net and a mat.
- Day session: 35–50 litres. Adds food, a flask, spare clothing and a second bait option.
- Overnight or 24 hours: 50 litres plus a separate bait bag and a rod holdall. At this point a bag becomes a duffel with a frame.
- Multi-night: stop treating it as a bag problem. You need a barrow or a trolley, not a bigger sack.
Oversized bags are the most common mistake. A 70-litre bag for a three-hour session is a bag you fill with things you never use, and then carry.
Waterproofing and weather
Three levels, and the difference matters more than the label suggests.
- Water-resistant. Coated fabric, no taped seams. Fine for damp grass and a shower; not for a full day of rain.
- Waterproof with taped seams and a storm flap. The practical standard for UK fishing. Check that the zip is covered, not just water-repellent.
- Fully submersible / dry bag. For boat work and kayaks, or for keeping a phone and spare clothing dry regardless of what happens to the main bag.
Whatever you buy, put documents, phone and a spare base layer in a small dry bag inside it. Bags leak at seams and around zips, and the contents are what actually matter.

Pockets, straps and access
- Wide-mouth opening. A bag you can see into is worth more than one with an extra pocket.
- Divided main compartment. Keeps bait away from dry clothing and stops everything migrating to one end.
- External tool loops. For forceps, a knife and a bank stick — things you want without opening the bag.
- Padded, adjustable straps. Weight on a fishing bag is lumps and points, not a smooth load. Straps matter more than on a hiking pack.
- A flat base. A bag that stands up on the bank does not put your kit in the mud.
- Reflective or light-coloured lining. Black interiors swallow small items and torch batteries.
What to pack for each session
A baseline that works, adjust to your water:
- Tackle: rig wallet, a small box of hooks and swivels, spare line, scissors, forceps, hook sharpener.
- Fish care: unhooking mat or cradle, weigh sling, scales, wet wipes or a towel.
- Bait: hookbaits, free offerings, a spare option in case the fish want something else.
- Personal: water, food, medication, phone in a dry bag, head torch with spare batteries.
- Clothing: a waterproof shell and a warm mid layer, even in summer. UK weather changes in an hour.
- Documents: rod licence confirmation and the venue ticket.
The GOV.UK fishing licence service lets you keep a digital licence on your phone, but a screenshot is useless with a flat battery — carry it in the dry bag.

Care and longevity
- Empty and dry it after every session. Bait residue and damp clothing are what rot a bag, not mud.
- Clean zips and re-lubricate them. Grit in a zip is the first thing to fail.
- Reproof the fabric when water stops beading — a wash-in or spray treatment restores the finish.
- Store it open and dry, not compressed in a shed.
- Do not overload the seams. A bag rated for 30 litres will fail at the handles if you force 50 into it.
How it fits with the rest of your kit
A bag is one part of the transport system. Hard items such as alarms, leads and hook packets belong in a tackle box inside the bag, not loose. If you are carrying a bedchair, bivvy and a week of food, the answer is a fishing trolley rather than a heavier rucksack — and once the barrow is in play, a carryall becomes the sensible bag because it sits flat and opens wide.
If you are still building a kit from nothing, start with our fishing starter kit guide and buy the bag to fit it, not the other way around. Everything else is in the fishing range.
FAQ
What size fishing bag do I need?
20–30 litres for short sessions, 35–50 litres for a full day. If you need more than 50 litres you usually need a trolley rather than a bigger bag.
Should I buy a rucksack or a carryall?
A rucksack if you walk to your swim; a carryall if you fish from a barrow or near the car. Many anglers end up with both.
Is a waterproof fishing bag worth the extra cost?
In the UK, yes — provided the seams are taped and the zips are covered. A "water-resistant" bag without taped seams is not a waterproof bag.
Can I use a hiking rucksack for fishing?
Yes, and often it is better made. The compromise is fewer external tool loops and tackle-specific pockets, plus a lack of divided compartments for bait.
How do I stop my fishing bag smelling?
Empty it after every session, remove bait residue, dry it fully open, and never pack damp clothing inside it. Smell comes from damp and old bait, not from the fabric.
Sources
- GOV.UK, Fishing licences — rod licence requirements, conditions and digital licences.
- Canal & River Trust, Fishing on our waterways — permits and rules on Trust-managed water.
- Met Office, Learn about the weather — why UK conditions change quickly and how to plan for rain.